How to Get Auto Insurance After an Accident
Getting into an accident can shake your confidence—and your insurance situation. Whether your insurer dropped you, raised your rates, or you simply want a better deal, you can still get strong coverage after a crash with the right strategy.
Quick Take
Watch: How to Get Car Insurance After an Accident
Want to Compare Auto Insurance the Smart Way?
Most drivers overpay for auto insurance simply because they compare quotes the wrong way. The Before You Buy: Auto Insurance Rate Comparison Guide shows you the exact step‑by‑step method smart shoppers use to compare coverage, spot hidden differences, avoid misleading “cheap” quotes, and find the best value fast. If you want lower rates without cutting coverage, this guide is the proven system that makes it easy.
Get the Guide
How insurers view accidents
Not all accidents affect your rates the same way. Insurers evaluate several factors to determine how risky you appear after a crash.
They look at:
- Fault: At‑fault accidents usually have the biggest impact.
- Severity: High‑cost claims raise rates more than minor fender‑benders.
- Frequency: Multiple accidents in a short period raise red flags.
- Timing: Recent accidents matter more than older ones.
Step 1: Confirm whether your insurer will keep you
After a serious accident, some insurers may choose not to renew your policy. Others may keep you but raise your premium. Before shopping around, check your renewal notice or call your insurer to understand your status.
Step 2: Gather your updated policy details
Before requesting new quotes, pull your declarations page and claim documents. You’ll need accurate information about:
- The date of the accident.
- Whether you were found at fault.
- The total payout amount.
- Any injuries or property damage involved.
Step 3: Shop multiple insurers—some are more forgiving
Different insurers weigh accidents differently. A company that penalizes you heavily may not be the same one that offers the best rate.
Include a mix of:
- National insurers.
- Regional carriers.
- Online/direct insurers.
- Independent agents who can quote multiple companies at once.
Step 4: Match your coverage when comparing quotes
To compare fairly, make sure every quote matches your current coverage:
- Liability limits.
- Comprehensive and collision.
- Deductibles.
- Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage.
- Rental, roadside, and other extras.
Step 5: Use discounts to offset the accident surcharge
Even after an accident, you may qualify for discounts that reduce your rate.
Ask about:
- Bundling home or renters insurance.
- Multi‑vehicle discounts.
- Autopay or paperless billing.
- Low‑mileage or usage‑based programs.
- Defensive driving courses (in some states).
Step 6: Consider telematics to prove safe driving
Telematics programs track your driving habits and reward safe behavior. After an accident, these programs can help rebuild your profile and reduce your rate faster than waiting for the accident to age off.
Step 7: Avoid choices that make the situation worse
After an accident, insurers watch your behavior closely. Avoid decisions that could compound the rate increase.
- Don’t let your policy lapse.
- Don’t switch insurers repeatedly for tiny savings.
- Don’t take on deductibles you can’t afford.
- Don’t ignore billing fees or missed discounts.
Quick comparison: Accident scenarios and what to expect
| Situation | Rate Impact | What Helps |
|---|---|---|
| Minor not‑at‑fault accident | Low to moderate | Shop around; some insurers ignore these |
| At‑fault accident with property damage | Moderate to high | Telematics, bundling, higher deductibles |
| At‑fault accident with injuries | High | Compare multiple insurers; consider regional carriers |
| Multiple accidents in 3 years | Very high | High‑risk insurers, then rebuild over time |
Common mistakes after an accident
⚠️ Mistake #1: Accepting the first renewal price without comparing alternatives.
⚠️ Mistake #2: Dropping important coverages to chase a lower premium.
⚠️ Mistake #3: Letting your policy lapse because the new rate feels too high.
⚠️ Mistake #4: Not asking about discounts that can offset the surcharge.
FAQ: Getting auto insurance after an accident
Will my rates always go up after an accident?
Not always. Some insurers forgive your first accident, especially if you’ve been claim‑free for years.
How long will the accident affect my rates?
Most insurers weigh accidents for 3–5 years, with the biggest impact in the first 12–24 months.
Can I switch insurers after an accident?
Yes. Many drivers find better rates by switching, especially if their current insurer penalizes them heavily.
Can telematics help after an accident?
Yes. Safe‑driving programs can reduce your rate faster than waiting for the accident to age off.
Final thoughts
Getting auto insurance after an accident is absolutely possible—and often easier than drivers expect. By comparing multiple insurers, matching your coverage, using discounts, and avoiding another lapse or violation, you can rebuild your profile and secure strong protection at a fair price.
Boss Block: Official Auto Insurance, Consumer Protection & Rate‑Setting Authorities
Trusted government, regulatory, and nonprofit organizations providing authoritative guidance on auto insurance pricing, renewal rules, consumer rights, and state‑level oversight.
Auto Insurance Consumer Guides
Insurance Information Institute (III)
How to Save on Auto Insurance
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB)
Insurance Consumer Tools & Rights
USA.gov
Auto Insurance Basics & Federal Resources
FTC Auto Insurance Consumer Protection
State Insurance Commissioners
Find Your State Insurance Department
National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA)
Driving Safety Resources
FINRA
Financial Education & Consumer Protection
